Subject: Re: IRIS opens up, 17 chem's requested for comment
Date: Wed, 07 Jan 1998 16:27:47 -0500

WARNING about the use of EPA's IRIS program.

Do not assume that if a substance is not listed in IRIS it is not toxic. A
great many toxic chemicals are not in the IRIS database including DIOXIN!

I ran into this dangerous situation when I was working with Teresa Mills
and the other folks in Columbus, Ohio in regard to their municipal
incinerator which was the greatest dioxin emitting incinerator in America.
The City Health Commissioner had been assuring the community that dioxin
was not toxic (this was in 1994!) This was accepted by the press, the
local government, and the community over the protestations of Teresa and
her colleagues. When I asked the Commissioner (an MD I believe) why he
thought dioxin wasn't toxic he explained that it was not in the EPA IRIS
database which he depended on as his source of toxic substances. I then
called the fellow who runs IRIS and he told me that there are many toxic
substances not included in IRIS and that IRIS is a database which depends
on voluntary submissions. Their only function is to check the accuracy of
the submissions.

I pointed out the danger of this by telling him of the Columbus experience
and he agreed that a warning of its incompleteness should be included with
the database.

That was in 1994. I just checked the IRIS web page and dioxin is still not
included and neither is the warning.

William Sanjour
Washington, DC 20460
Voice Mail: 703-603-9931
Fax: 703-603-9135

William Sanjour's home page

Free counters provided by Honesty Communications.